livescore

Nations League News: Top-class Trafford lays claim to England No.1 spot with Madrid heroics

Published:
Will EvansWill Evans
England’s James Trafford (centre) excelled in goal as Spain launched a second-half onslaught at Estadio Metropolitano
England’s James Trafford (centre) excelled in goal as Spain launched a second-half onslaught at Estadio Metropolitano

If Sunday’s clash with Spain was a de facto audition for England’s No.1 berth then James Trafford passed with flying colours.

The Leeds United stopper produced a sensational second-half showing at Estadio Metropolitano, as Thomas Tuchel’s men triumphed 3-2 in testing circumstances.

Having taken a 3-0 lead and seemingly in complete control, the visitors needed their goalkeeper to step up after a 63rd-minute red card for Elliot Anderson.

And though La Roja pulled two goals back, Trafford’s heroics ensured England came away from Madrid with a statement victory to top Nations League ‘League A’ Group 3.

So, has the 24-year-old done enough to unseat long-term incumbent Jordan Pickford as the Three Lions’ first-choice custodian?

We assess the current state of play with the goalkeeping department, following an instructive pair of matches against Croatia and Spain.

Seizing a surprise opportunity

There was plenty of intrigue around England’s goalkeeper position heading into this international break.

Tuchel had set the cat amongst the pigeons during the previous round of Nations League fixtures, when he decided to split minutes between the established Pickford and challenger Trafford.

It was Trafford who featured against Spain and Czechia, before his more experienced counterpart took the gloves for October’s 7-0 thumphing of Croatia and the return meeting with the Czechs.

Tuchel maintained that Pickford was his first choice prior to last week’s rematch against Croatia, however, saying:

“No, he [Pickford] is [No.1]. But nothing has changed. The competition is on there as well, like for the outfield players.”

With that in mind, it was a little curious that the Everton man was chosen to start against Slaven Bilić’s team on Thursday, while Trafford played in Sunday’s ‘showpiece’ fixture versus Spain.

But there can be no doubt the now five-cap international seized his opportunity, even if it came about in somewhat surprising circumstances.

A breakthrough performance

Pickford can count himself unfortunate that the 2-1 win over Croatia at Wembley offered few chances to impress, even if Tuchel is already well aware of his qualities.

The 32-year-old had little to do for much of that game – and there was no realistic prospect of him keeping out Petar Sučić’s 59th-minute strike.

It looked to be heading the same way for Trafford, too, as a phenomenal England showing saw them go 3-0 up before the hour mark against Spain.

Luis de la Fuente’s team hadn’t tested the Cumbrian keeper whatsoever until that point, but that all changed when Anderson saw red and conceded a penalty with 63 minutes on the clock.

Trafford was sent the wrong way by Mikel Oyarzabal for the spot kick, though he more than made amends in the period that followed.

He got down low to his right to stop Lamine Yamal’s long-range effort on 79 minutes, before keeping out Marc Cucurella’s strike at the near post mere seconds later.

But the pièce de résistance was a simply outrageous double save in stoppage time – first from Fermín López, then immediately recovering to spring rightwards and thwart Aymeric Laporte.

A total of six saves across the 90 minutes only tells half the story, as Trafford came up with the goods in England’s time of need.

James Trafford of England makes a save during the UEFA Nations League 2026/27 group phase match between Spain and England at Wanda Metropolitano on November 15, 2026 in Madrid, Spain
Goalkeeper James Trafford helped keep Spain at bay as ten-man England triumphed 3-2 in Madrid

Tuchel yet to commit

Despite Trafford’s stand-out showing, Tuchel stopped short of saying he would be England’s No.1 going forward.

Speaking after the match, he said: “There’s no ‘No.1’.

“It’s a good double save. That’s exactly what we wanted and he had a brilliant match, because it only works if you’re top from number one to 11.”

And the German tactician later stated: “[Trafford was] Very good. That’s his job, to close the gap. We want competition in all positions.

“We need to see Trafford in high-pressure moments. The obvious save, where he deserves full credit, is the double save at the very end. Absolutely brilliant.

“There was a lot to do in the deep build-up as well, which he did very, very well, with everyone around him.

“Never lose the concentration, never lose the focus, never lose the vision where to find the free men to overcome the press and put the game to the opponent’s half.

“With everyone else, he was part of a fantastic team performance.”

It is understandable that Tuchel is being cautious, having witnessed exactly how influential Pickford can be for the Three Lions.

The 6ft1 in stopper has delivered time and time again across 94 appearances for England, so has plenty of credit in the bank.

But having opened the door for Trafford to stake his claim, it will be hard to drop him after he walked through it with such aplomb.

Jordan Pickford of England during the UEFA Nations League 2026/27 group phase match between England and Croatia at Wembley Stadium on November 12, 2026 in London, England
Jordan Pickford’s performances for England over nine years have arguably earned a degree of loyalty from his manager

Club form counts

International football only provides us with a small sample size to work off when comparing goalkeepers, such is the minimal number of fixtures played each year.

So both Trafford and Pickford’s form at club level could play a significant part in who gets the nod when the Nations League continues in March.

There are 20 rounds of Premier League action before a two-legged quarter-final against a League A runner-up, with the draw for that tie to be held on Friday (20th November, 11am GMT).

As such, the two competing custodians will have ample opportunity to showcase their talents with Leeds United and Everton, respectively.

James Trafford of Leeds United during the Premier League 2026/27 match between Leeds United and Tottenham Hotspur at Elland Road on November 7, 2026 in Leeds, United Kingdom
Leeds United have only conceded eight times in the Premier League this season with James Trafford between the sticks

Early signs suggest it could be a close-fought battle, with both stoppers performing admirably so far this season.

They have kept four clean sheets apiece in the Premier League to date and are ranked third and fourth for goals conceded – Leeds leaking just eight goals and Everton’s back line only being breached ten times.

Notably, it is Trafford who has needed to be more active to maintain that record, making 37 saves to Pickford’s 28.

The Leeds keeper has made one clear error leading to a goal, however, which isn’t the case for his counterpart on Merseyside.

But where Trafford really excels is save percentage. He has the best record in the entire division when we subtract goals conceded from shots on target against, and divide that number by the total shots on target allowed.

The resulting figure of 82.2% is significantly higher than any other Premier League glovesman and some way above Pickford’s 73.7%.

The opposite is true when we look at expected goals on target (xGOT) conceded, though.

Everton’s No.1 comes out with 11.05 vs 12.36, when we only factor in opposition xG that resulted in an on-target effort at goal.

Perhaps the jury is still out, then, but a clearer picture is sure to emerge before the next pause in the domestic football calendar.

It will certainly be fascinating to observe the battle between these two high-quality goalkeepers in the weeks and months ahead.

Discover more from LiveScore
Never miss an update. Add LiveScore as a preferred source on Google for the latest news and match predictions.
add preferred sourceAdd
NewsFootball NewsUEFA Nations League News
Nations League News: Top-class Trafford lays claim to England No.1 spot with Madrid heroics