Conte challenges Spalletti and Inzaghi: why Juventus should bring him back, and why they should not
Choose who plays the Good, the Ugly and the Bad in this black-and-white western, with the Juventus job for 2026-27 as the prize. This season is still under way, but the club's plans and the fans' dreams have already turned to the future. The same refrain has played out every season since 2020.
The three-way showdown
For now, Luciano Spalletti remains in charge of Juve despite a poor start to the league campaign, though things have gone better in the Europa League. His contract runs until 2028. Meanwhile, transfer rumours suggest Simone Inzaghi is chief executive Giovanni Carnevali's preferred manager for Juventus' future. Then a familiar face enters the showdown: Antonio Conte, whose explosive interview with Cronache di Spogliatoio sees him play his ace: “Juve and I have a circle that sooner or later we will have to close”.
Three names for one job, with seven months of the current season still to play. Each brings different qualities, strengths and weaknesses. Here are the pros and cons of Spalletti, Inzaghi and Conte.
Spalletti: pros and cons
Luciano Spalletti has experience on his side and, above all, has already spent a year working with Juventus and the current group of players. Keeping him, regardless of how this season goes, would give Juve the continuity in the dugout and stability they have lacked for years (six managers since 2019: Sarri, Pirlo, Allegri, Motta, Tudor and Spalletti). The concerns are a degree of confusion in Spalletti's tactical ideas and communication: his spell at Juve looks closer to his poor spell with the national team than to his intuitive, winning spell at Napoli.
Inzaghi: pros and cons
With Simone Inzaghi, two things stand out: first, he works within the club's plans, like Allegri. He does not cause trouble over transfers and makes do with the squad he is given, perhaps banging his fists in private but never in public. Second, Inzaghi has shown he is a modern manager who can adapt to both the Italian league and European football. The concerns include doubts about his ability to handle the pressure of key moments in a season (with Inter, partly because of players' mistakes, Radu's among them, he lost two Serie A titles that were within Inter's reach) and a degree of tactical rigidity, tied to his beloved 3-5-2.
Conte: pros and cons
Antonio Conte comes with drawbacks. The manager from Salento demands a high salary (at least 8 million, while Spalletti earns 5 million and Inzaghi would require 6 million) and wants a say in the transfer market. Those demands give a club plenty to weigh up. Other concerns may be clichés, but football has come to treat them as facts: with Conte, a project can last no more than two years, with Conte, public communication can be difficult to manage, and with Conte, the squad must give everything, at the risk of burning out.
Conte also has compelling points in his favour, which football regards as established truths: with Conte, you win the Serie A title within two years or, at worst, finish second (tell that to Juve, who have been nowhere near the top places for years). Conte also lays foundations that other managers can use to keep winning (Allegri at Juve, Inzaghi at Inter).
Perhaps the most important factor is 'juventinità', the sense of Juventus identity. Many Juventus fans have felt betrayed by Conte three times (when he resigned in 2014, when he chose Inter, when he chose Napoli). Yet his words in the interview with Cronache already point towards a reconciliation. Surely one press conference and a few wins would be enough to put things back where they belong: the former captain and former leader once again at the helm of Juventus.
The decision
Juventus need everyone at the club to agree on their choice. John Elkann, the main driving force behind Spalletti's contract extension, must be the first to want Conte back. So far, Juve's owners have never wanted to consider Antonio's return and have never forgiven him for the betrayal of 2014. Forgiveness must come first. Then every director must back Conte (or keeping Spalletti, or appointing Inzaghi): Carnevali, Massara, Ottolini and Chiellini. The worst outcome for Juventus would be to choose their manager for 2027-28 without everyone's backing.