Maestro – “It’s my book, my story, my life,” Celtic legend Paul McStay
Paul McStay finally tells his story: Celtic legend lifts lid on Rangers approach, His Celtic exit and the truth behind his retirement…
The Celtic icon has released his long-awaited autobiography, Maestro, giving supporters a fascinating insight into a remarkable one-club playing career, the difficult final chapter of his playing for Celtic story and the moment Rangers tried to tempt him across Glasgow.
For generations of Celtic supporters, Paul McStay represents everything that made the club special. A homegrown talent, a magnificent footballer and a captain who remained loyal through some of the most difficult years in Celtic’s history, the former midfielder occupies a special place in the club’s history.
Now, almost three decades after bringing his playing career to an end, the Celtic legend has finally put his story into print with his independently published and long awaited autobiography titled Maestro.
Paul McStay launched his long-awaited autobiography, Maestro yesterday with the book already attracting considerable attention following a series of revelations about his time at Celtic.
And there is plenty for supporters to get their teeth into. From an extraordinary approach from Rangers to the circumstances surrounding his departure from Celtic in 1997, McStay has decided that the time is right to tell his story in his own words.
For a much loved and admired Celtic legend whose loyalty to the Celtic cause was never at any stage in question, some of the revelations are particularly interesting.
The Rangers approach that never stood a chance
Perhaps the most eye-catching revelation concerns the summer of 1992, when Rangers FC were enjoying a period of domestic success under Walter Smith.
Paul McStay was approaching a significant crossroads in his career. Celtic were struggling financially, Rangers were strengthening their squad and the midfielder was considering his future, with interest from clubs in England and in particular Italy.
However, there was another possibility that would have sent shockwaves through Scottish football. Rangers FC made an indirect approach about taking McStay to Ibrox, with Smith using a mutual contact to discover whether the Celtic captain might consider following the path taken by Judas three years earlier.
McStay confirmed the approach yesterday afternoon when discussing the contents of his autobiography at Lesser Hampden.
“That was a question put to me in ’92, yes,” the Maestro explained. “It was a polite ‘no thanks’. I think that’s the best way of putting it.”
It is difficult to imagine how Celtic supporters would have reacted had their captain made such a move, particularly given his importance to the club and the relationship he had built with the support.
Interestingly, McStay was also keen to acknowledge the relationship he shared with Walter Smith, despite the Rangers connection.
“When you talk about mentors and things like that, Walter was up there,” he said. He went on to explain how Smith had been involved with Scotland’s youth teams during the early stages of his career, alongside manager Andy Roxburgh.
“Since then, there’s always been a bond. He is a wonderful man and obviously, he did well at Rangers, which had an effect on me. But as a person, I got on really well with Walter.”
For Celtic supporters, the important part of the story is that McStay never seriously entertained the possibility of crossing the Glasgow divide. Nor did he opt to leave Celtic to play in Italy or England but instead he allowed his heart to run his head by remaining at a Celtic in crisis, ultimately finishing his career having represented only one club at senior level.
Why McStay wanted to tell his own story
The autobiography’s publication has also brought an interesting situation between McStay and Celtic into the spotlight. The former Celtic captain had initially hoped to launch the book in partnership with the club, potentially at Celtic Park, during an earlier visit to Scotland.
However, those plans eventually fell through after Celtic presented him with an agreement that would have allowed the club to approve the contents before publication. The request has been portrayed in a negative light as far as Celtic is concerned but, while we don’t know the exact reasons, this isn’t an unusual request from a book publisher for all sorts of legal and commercial reasons.
Celtic are not the bad guys here, nor is Paul. It’s simply a matter of parties not being able to agree on the terms of the book publishing deal.
So Paul McStay decided against signing it to maintain his complete editorial control and that seems fair enough. Explaining his decision, he was keen to stress that he had no desire to create controversy or settle scores with people at the club.
Instead, he wanted the freedom to tell his story without having to obtain approval from anybody else.
“It’s my book, my story, my life. So I just said, I couldn’t sign the agreement. I’ll do my own thing,” he explained.
He also acknowledged that Celtic had been helpful during the initial discussions, making clear that his decision was about retaining control over the finished publication. “I decided to do my own thing and I’ve been quite honest in it.”
McStay added that there were certain elements of the book that Celtic were uncomfortable with at the time.“You’ll read through it, there’s nothing controversial. But there were certain things that they weren’t comfortable with at the time.”
That is particularly significant given the subject matter surrounding his eventual departure. For years, McStay’s retirement has been discussed as one of the more disappointing endings to an otherwise magnificent Celtic career. Now, the former midfielder believes supporters deserve to understand exactly what happened from his perspective.
The difficult ending to a Celtic career
McStay’s departure from Celtic in 1997 is clearly one of the main reasons he felt compelled to publish his autobiography and tell his Celtic story. After 16 years in the first team, the midfielder was forced to confront the reality that injuries were catching up with him. Problems with his ankle had become increasingly serious, with medical examinations revealing the extent of the damage.
Despite attempting to fight his way back through rehabilitation, retirement eventually became unavoidable. However, the circumstances surrounding his departure left a bitter taste.
Paul believes the version of events that emerged at the time did not accurately reflect what had happened behind the scenes.“The exit wasn’t great,” he admitted. “I never ever thought I’d leave Celtic in that way. There were a lot of good times along the way, as well as ups and downs.”
He was particularly keen to address what he considers inaccurate reporting around his final months at the club.“But to me, it was very important to get that message out about how it ended. Because even at that time, there was a bit of PR coming out about certain things. And it wasn’t quite accurate.”
The former captain also revealed that he had become accustomed to giving supporters a shortened version of events whenever he was asked about his retirement“. People ask me about leaving Celtic I always sort of give a sanitised version and say, ‘Oh, it didn’t work out’.”
He recalled somebody even suggesting that he had simply walked away from Celtic while he was living in Sydney. “That’s not quite what happened.”
Paul McStay says he has included names and details in the book, explaining that notes were taken at the time and that he is comfortable with what has been written.“I don’t have a go at anybody through it. It’s just about telling the story and that was very important for me.”
For supporters who watched McStay throughout his Celtic career, this promises to be one of the most interesting sections of Maestro. I remember his debut, then that goal up at Pittodrie and the excitement about this very special young player who every Celtic supporter already knew about after his exploits for Scotland U18s beating England 5-4 at Wembley.
Hyped up players inevitably let you down to some extent or other but NOT Paul McStay. NEVER Paul McStay.He delivered from day one and went on doing so until the day he left the club. Davie Provan was a fine Celtic winger but the Wednesday night he scored against Rangers was perhaps the only time a Celtic goal against them was met with just 0.001% of regret. It was Celtic’s third in a 3-0 win over the original Ibrox club at Celtic Park and the two McStay Bhoys, Willie and Paul had scored the first two goals.
A Celtic connection that has never disappeared
Despite spending much of the last 16 years living in Australia, McStay’s connection with Celtic has never really disappeared. His name continues to feature in one of the club’s most familiar songs, with supporters regularly singing about the legendary midfielder alongside James McGrory, Jimmy Johnstone, Charlie Tully, Bobby Murdoch, Bertie Auld and Davie Hay. That’s high quality company to keep and the Maestro certainly merits his place.
It is a remarkable tribute to a player whose influence stretched across different generations of the Celtic support. McStay acknowledged that the song became part of the supporters’ repertoire after his retirement.
“James McStay was actually in the original song and then, through time, the younger generations changed it to Paul,” the Maestro explained.
His return to Scotland for the autobiography launch has also coincided with his involvement in the Willie Haughey initiative, the Celtic Season Ticket Alliance, where he has been supporting efforts to give supporters a greater voice in the club’s running.
Paul has been vocal about the importance of communication between Celtic’s boardroom and supporters, revealing that he recently spoke with chief executive Michael Nicholson. It is another indication that, despite his relatively low public profile since moving to Australia, McStay remains invested in the future of the club he served so loyally.
He is also expected to attend Celtic’s home match against St Mirren on Saturday, giving supporters an opportunity to welcome him back to Celtic Park.
A book Celtic supporters will want to read
There are plenty of former Celtic players who have enjoyed hugely successful careers, but few have the standing of Paul McStay. After the Lisbon Lions we could add Danny McGrain, Kenny Dalglish, Paul McStay and Henrik Larsson to the list of Celtic’s greatest ever players in living memory.
The Maestro played for Celtic some good times in the 1980s and also through a difficult period later in his career. He experienced the unforgettable highs Love Street ’86 and of the 1988 centenary celebrations and remained committed when Celtic were struggling to compete with a financially doped Rangers.
His penalty miss against Raith Rovers in the shoot-out at Ibrox had them ‘dancing in the streets of Raith’ (aka Kirkcaldy) and it was a low point for many of us that day as we desperately wanted to end our 1990s trophy doubt. And it hurt the Celtic support more because it was the Maestro who missed the decisive spot kick.
His hurt was ours too that day. It was all the worse because it was HIM who missed it. No-one wanted that for the Maestro.
Paul’s 1995 Scottish Cup success as Celtic captain under Tommy Burns provided a memorable moment as the drought ended. This triumph was the start of something big and it was also the subject of the late, great David Potters first ever Celtic book!
It was fitting that Paul would experience the joy of lifting a trophy for Celtic before injury eventually brought his playing days to an end.
In August 2025 at a media conference at Lennoxtown I asked the then Celtic manager Brendan Rodgers if he’s like to have a young Paul McStay in his Celtic team at that time. Here’s how Brendan replied:
“Paul would probably play in two positions for me,” Brendan told me. “He was amazing. When the club spoke to me and told me that there was the possibility of him coming to do the flag day, I went into my boy mode again.
“What an amazing icon of the club he is. It’s just a shame you don’t see so much of him, he’s obviously on the other side of the world now. But that was my memories growing up – with Paul in the team. He is just an icon of the club, such a humble guy.
“I had the privilege of meeting him for the first time when I was here. He came into my office and it was just brilliant. To see him on Sunday will be amazing. He was such an icon at such a tough time for Celtic. I can’t speak highly enough of him.
“I don’t know Paul that well, but I know many people who do I was struck by the humility of the guy when I met him. All I really wanted to do was bow at his feet.”
Honour the Maestro, buy the book
Maestro promises to offer supporters something more than a collection of memories from a celebrated football career. It is mild mannered Paul McStay’s opportunity to explain the decisions, relationships and difficult moments that shaped his time at Celtic, including stories that have remained largely untold until now.
And given the revelations already emerging from the launch, there is every reason to believe the autobiography will generate plenty of discussion among the Celtic support. For a player whose name will forever be associated with the club, it is fitting that he has finally decided to tell his story honestly, without any PR spin and from the heart.