David’s Heel: The Architectural Blindness of the Celtic Old Guard
David’s Heel: The Architectural Blindness of the Celtic Old Guard…
In the cold, unforgiving realm of corporate governance, there is no room for mythology. Yet for decades, the Celtic support has been fed a steady diet of it…
We have been told tales of masterful corporate architects, seasoned operators who supposedly understood every single brick in the Parkhead boardroom fortress. We were told to sit down, stay quiet, and leave the strategy to the professionals.
But when you strip away the PR gloss and pull the actual engineering schematics of Celtic PLC, a much darker reality emerges.
If Celtic Supporters Limited (CSL) had been around in ancient Greece, the myth of the unassailable warrior wouldn’t belong to Achilles. It would be rewritten as David’s Heel.
I am not against the CSL. I am for the CSL
Let me be unequivocal on this: I am not against the CSL. I am for the CSL. They are, as I have always seen, one of the very few organisations that possess the structural capability to cause genuine, lasting change. I remain 100% for them, and I am 100% behind their current strategy of tactical voting.
We would all love nothing more than to see this boardroom completely replaced at the upcoming AGM on 1 December 2026. But under the current setup, that is mathematically impossible in a single day. Why?
Because when it comes to voting out directors, the board only needs a simple majority (over 50%) to win. Between Dermot Desmond, Lindsell Train, and a few close allies, the boardroom controls a permanent 51% chunk of the voting power. They can use that combined weight like an immovable wall to block standard fan votes.
Transforming this club is going to take time. How much time? Nobody knows. It could move significantly quicker now that—
THE REAL EXPERTS—THE LAWYERS AND THE TAKEOVER PANEL
—are finally dealing with it.
Now to the AGM
This is where boardroom maths collides directly with terrace reality. Ahead of Celtic plc’s General Meeting and AGM on 1 December 2026, the biggest battle is developing around a move by the board to rewrite the club’s Articles of Association—effectively Celtic’s internal company rulebook—alongside a fierce debate over tactical voting and some sharp comments from Celtic Supporters Limited (CSL) director David Low.
What Is the Board Trying to Change?
For the first time since 2011, Celtic is asking shareholders to approve an updated rulebook at a separate General Meeting at 9:30 am, right before the main AGM gets underway at noon. While the club describes this as routine housekeeping, two proposals have raised serious alarm bells among supporters:
Scrapping show-of-hands votes. Decisions would be settled strictly by share-weighted polls, taking away a visible way for ordinary fans in the room to register their feelings.
Moving meetings online. The board would gain the power to shift meetings online if an in-person gathering is disrupted or adjourned—a direct reaction to the chaotic scenes that forced last year’s AGM to be abandoned early.
To pass these changes, the board needs a 75% supermajority of the votes cast. To put that simply: standard votes at the AGM only need a simple majority (over 50%) to win, meaning the board can easily use its massive institutional backing to block standard fan resolutions.
Changing the club’s actual rulebook, however, requires a Special Resolution. This means the board needs a massive 75% of the total shares voted on the day to get its way. If just over 25% of the shares vote “No,” the rule changes are completely blocked. This is a critical constitutional gate where the board’s standard 51% institutional fortress isn’t enough on its own to guarantee an effortless victory.
Why Has David Low Sparked Such Anger?
Speaking on a recent podcast, David Low appeared completely unprofessional and perhaps hung over, he commented on it himself on live media, a choice he probably regrets. I also think the host should have done his due diligence and asked for another day, Low arguing that the hostile disruption at last year’s AGM handed the board the exact excuse it needed to propose tighter controls this time around.
He dismissed blanket “vote everyone out” protest campaigns as achieving nothing, defending CSL’s decision to vote for five directors—including Michael Nicholson and interim chairman Brian Wilson—while opposing only Dermot Desmond and James Mark Keane.
In return for backing those five directors, CSL secured the board’s agreement to hire a specialist firm to trace and reactivate roughly 20% of Celtic’s dormant shares—potentially bringing thousands of missing fan shareholders back into play.
On paper, Low’s logic is about long-term leverage. Under UK company law, fans don’t need to own 51% of the club to hold real power. Controlling 5% lets supporters force resolutions onto the AGM agenda, and reaching 25.1% gives them a legal veto to block rulebook changes like the ones being proposed on 1 December.
The campaigner groups were completely weaponless. They were fighting a modern corporate machine with emotional slogans. Naming the blind spot—and urging CSL to finally use it as genuine leverage—has completely shattered the illusion of boardroom invulnerability. The old guard didn’t fail to act because they lacked the tools; they failed to act because they lacked the foresight.
Where the Logic Falls Short for Everyday Fans
While tracing dormant shares to build future fan power makes sense in theory, two major flaws have left many supporters angry.
First, there is the question of tone and unity. By talking down to fellow supporters, appearing unprofessional and hung over on live media, and mocking grassroots protests, Low has alienated the very people needed to build a unified fan bloc. This hands the board a public relations victory at a time when many fans want the entire leadership held accountable.
Second—and most importantly—judging fan frustration purely through corporate voting maths misses the basic reality of football. The vast majority of Celtic supporters do not own shares.
Everyday fans who spend thousands of pounds on season tickets, away days, and merchandise—but aren’t in a financial position to buy shares in a public limited company—have zero formal vote at an AGM. When match-going supporters are unhappy with how the club is run, banners, chants, and collective protests are often the only voice they have.
If voted through at the earlier 9:30 am meeting, because of the board’s new electronic adjournment escape routes, groups like the Celtic Fan Collective have to get much more creative with their protests without disrupting the actual proceedings of the AGM.
Disruption inside the room merely hands the executive hierarchy a ready-made excuse to shut down the physical gathering. Real pressure must look outward, bypassing the board’s closed-door rules.
The viral “Where’s Desmond?” campaign is a phenomenal blueprint of what this looks like in practice. What started on a small podcast in the southern hemisphere has gained incredible traction across the entire global diaspora, turning a localised boardroom critique into an international awareness movement.
By plastering posters in major cities and global transit destinations far and wide, fans are visibly showcasing Desmond’s absenteeism from the AGM to the world, creating a type of public pressure that no corporate rulebook update can filter out or suppress.
The Bottom Line: All Is Not Lost
Gaining genuine shareholder power is the only way fans can force permanent accountability inside the boardroom. On that long-term goal, unlocking dormant shares is a smart move.
But you cannot build a mass supporter movement while belittling the fans who fill the stadium every week.
Shareholders may own the paper stock, but match-going supporters are the lifeblood of Celtic—and any strategy that forgets that is fighting with one hand tied behind its back.
Crucially, when it comes to the board’s attempt to rewrite the rulebook at 9:30 am, all is not lost.
The defeatist narrative says that the board’s institutional fortress is completely unassailable. But the cold, hard corporate governance data proves otherwise. When you add up the core boardroom allies—Dermot Desmond (34.44%), Lindsell Train (~16.84%), Christopher Trainer (11.02%), James Mark Keane (6.25%), Tom Allison (3.55%), and Peter Lawwell (0.37%)—their collective maximum strength only reaches roughly 70.5%.
Even if they scrape together secondary institutional wealth funds like Lombard Odier (1.17%), the board’s absolute ceiling maxes out at around 72.65%. They are mathematically short. They cannot pass these sweeping rulebook changes on their own.
But let’s not be naive: in the shadowy depths of a PLC share register, we never know for sure who else is holding un-declared blocks just under the 3% reporting threshold. Historical family trusts, friendly corporate allies, and wealthy network insiders could easily hold the hidden percentages the board needs to quietly tip themselves over the 75% finishing line.
It is a long shot, but it is absolutely worth trying. Because we cannot see their hidden numbers, the independent support cannot afford to gamble on assumptions. Supporter apathy is the exact cushion the board relies on to bridge that un-declared gap.
This means the ultimate deciding block isn’t a group of wealthy boardroom insiders—it is the thousands of ordinary retail fan shareholders who collectively hold 15% to 20% of the club. Because a 75% supermajority is calculated strictly on the share volume of votes cast on the day, a fan share that stays silent is a vote that helps the board.
If ordinary retail fan shareholders fail to mobilise their active “No” proxies on 1 December, we aren’t just letting the known billionaires win—we are letting the board’s hidden shadows pass the new rulebook completely unchecked.
The veto power belongs to the support. If the ordinary shareholding fanbase mobilises and uses its active proxy voice to register a “No” block on 1 December, the board can be frozen right at the gates at 9:30 am.
Later in the day, when the clock strikes noon for the AGM proper, that session should be primarily for questions, as votes at this present stage don’t do much.
On a personal note, this has been an absolute slog to write as I’m ill with the dreaded lurgy, and I’m off to my bed.
Colin Dempster
HAVE YOUR SAY – Join the Celtic conversation in our comments section below…