livescore
Charlie Mulgrew takes on Martin O'Neill vs Brendan Rodgers vs Ange Postecoglou Celtic question

Charlie Mulgrew takes on Martin O'Neill vs Brendan Rodgers vs Ange Postecoglou Celtic question

Jamie Kemble
The Celtic Bhoys
Jamie Kemble

Charlie Mulgrew has taken on the question of Martin O'Neill vs Brendan Rodgers vs Ange Postecoglou.

The three Celtic bosses have very different approaches to football, and that is obvious to even the least knowledgeable football fan. Current (and former) boss O'Neill is not one for detailed tactics.

He likes direct football, getting the ball to wingers, taking on full-backs and attacking the goal. That has evolved over recent years, with slightly more tactical coaches working under O'Neill, and it's no secret that the veteran isn't the one doing the coaching on the training pitch.

O'Neill is a master man-manager, and his focus lies beyond modern football tactics, including the press.

Then you have Brendan Rodgers, who wants his side to show patience in their attacks, attacking with purpose as and when the time is right, but he wants to dominate the ball. Postecoglou, meanwhile, wants to attack quickly, rotate players throughout positions and press like animals.

There is no right way to win a football game, but what does former Celtic star Mulgrew make of the differences between the three?

He said on The Breakdown: “Put it this way, right? If Martin O’Neill had me, Scott Brown, Joe Ledley, Mark Wilson, to name a few. If he had us in that dressing room when we played, we would have that whole building behind the manager.

“The reason is because we were brought up in a generation that wasn’t tactics. We took responsibility for what we did. We would just say, ‘we need to win games’, so we would take responsibility. There would never be any tactics.

“There’s a generation of players there that have been brought up with tactics. With a clear identity, with unbelievable organisation. When I talk about Brendan Rodgers and Ange Postecoglou, you name those two managers in recent times that have been really successful, where trebles were really normal.

“Now those boys are going. That’s what they see as normal. This generation has been brought up with a tactical side. We never got tactics. If it wasn’t going right, Neil Lennon would two-foot the tactics board and go nuts at us.

“If anyone turned around and said ‘He was out of order with the way he spoke to us’, Aye, he was, but we should win games! Just win the game. It’s a different generation. This generation of players now demand a certain way and guidance. The level of football has went to another level of information.

“For example, I’d love to see an Ange Postecoglou team or a Brendan Rodgers team play against Martin O’Neill’s team. Personnel-wise, you would obviously go, ‘Martin O’Neill’s team would batter them’. But I don’t think Martin O’Neill’s team would get the ball off of Ange Postecoglou’s Celtic, because they wouldn’t press.

“Big John Hartson wouldn’t be able to press. But if they got a set piece, you would have Larsson, Sutton, Hartson, Mjallby, Varga, Bobo Balde… you would only have Carter-Vickers, who would [look small] amongst them.

“When I see a Brendan Rodgers or an Ange Postecoglou team… they would keep the ball off them, but it didn’t mean they would win. Because the minute Celtic get a goal kick, they would kick it up to Sutton, who would ragdoll someone, and it would drop to Larsson, and Petrov would run off the back of him…

“It would be some game to watch. I don’t know who would win, but it would be two different generations.”

An interesting assessment, and the reality of it is that there may be a different winner on a different day. We see more basic teams beating possession-based or pressing teams quite often, and vice versa. Much if also comes down to desire and who executes on the day, such is the nature of football.

Today's best reads

NewsFootball NewsScottish Premiership News
Charlie Mulgrew takes on Martin O'Neill vs Brendan Rodgers vs Ange Postecoglou Celtic question