Celtic Supporters Ltd chair hits back at criticism and vows to avoid 'insanity' approach
Celtic Supporters Limited chairman Duncan Smillie has hit back at fans who claim the group is doing the board's bidding by backing five directors for re-election.
The annual AGM is fast approaching, taking place on December 1, and it will be a big meeting after the disaster that was last year's AGM. That AGM featured an angry statement from Ross Desmond that triggered an even angrier reaction from fan shareholders, leading to the meeting being cut short.
It's hoped this year's meeting will be more cordial, with Celtic fans hoping to have more of an opportunity to ask questions of the club's board this time around.
In the lead up to it, Celtic Supporters Limited have backed the re-election of five directors, but they have withheld backing for Dermot Desmond and Mark Keane.
Many fans have hit back of that decision due to wanting the current board replaced, but the group's chair, Smillie, says it is little more than a strategic approach.
“It might sound crazy, but it’s not really an endorsement," Smillie told the Daily Record. "Our approach to this is that you’ve got to be tactical. A mass vote to remove everybody from the board isn’t realistic.
“This isn’t The Godfather where you wipe out all your enemies in one night at the same time. For us, you’ve got to be really tactical. The ‘sack the board’ mentality… it’s a metaphor this time. It was a real thing back in the 90s.
“There’s a way to remove boards, and it’s not just by having a mass protest vote. We’re very much splitting it between executive and shareholders. If you remove the exec and you put the same shareholders, then they just put the same sort of people in place.
“It’s not unconditional. It’s very much on three conditions that we’re voting for them. And that is that they do publish a strategy for the next three to five years covering football operations as well as the corporate side.
“And that the nomination and remuneration committees become independent of the major shareholders that are making those decisions today. And that all shareholder questions are answered by the AGM and future ones, and they don’t take this offline and take it off the grid.
“I’ve seen a little bit of criticism that we’re board patsies, we’re board apologists and all those things. That’s simply just not true. I can’t convince other people on what to think.”
He added: “People online can be pretty wild on their takes. If I said I was giving away free sweeties to everybody online, people would find a problem with it. There’s always people online that have different views, different opinions. That’s the world in which we live in.
“We’ve been very consistent in our approach. We’re not going to do what everybody’s done before. There’s some basic definition of insanity wrapped up in that statement there. We’re not going to keep doing the same things that other groups and other people have done. We want to take a more strategic and a more tactical approach to this.
“Hands up, we maybe could have been a little bit better and got ahead of it in terms of our comms as to why we were doing it. But the world moves very quickly. We should have been ahead of that in terms of the comms and given the reasons why. But that wouldn’t have changed the decision that we came to as a board and as a group of members. Maybe we could have communicated it better. But we believe it’s the right thing to do. It’s more a sniper approach than a machine gun.”