Celtic figures privately back Ian Joy as CBS pundit reveals behind-the-scenes messages
Scottish-American pundit Ian Paul Joy has revealed that figures inside Celtic have privately backed his criticism of the club’s European ambitions, claiming the Hoops are operating with a fear of failure.
The CBS Sports analyst has attracted considerable attention this season for his outspoken assessments of Celtic’s performances in Europe and the club’s approach to investment.
Joy, who previously played for St Pauli, Hamburg and Portland Timbers, has regularly questioned whether Celtic’s financial stability has come at the expense of meaningful progress on the European stage.
His criticism has resonated with sections of the Celtic support, particularly following the club’s disappointing Champions League play-off elimination against LASK.
Speaking to The Herald, Joy revealed that individuals within Celtic have contacted him directly following his viral comments, with the majority expressing support for his views.
Asked whether he had received any response from inside the club, Joy said:
“Yes, I have. I won’t mention any names, but since these videos have gone online, I have certainly had a few responses from people within.
“But the majority of them have actually been positive. Nobody has come out and said, ‘Ian, you’re talking a lot of bol—s!’ They’ve actually said, ‘Ian, you’re spot on. There needs to be a mentality change. We need to go in a new direction now.’”
Despite acknowledging Celtic’s financial strength, Joy believes the club’s board must place more emphasis on delivering European success rather than simply maintaining a healthy balance sheet.
He continued: “There’s a lot of good and a lot of bad I can say about Celtic. As a business, they are run incredibly well. But is that really what their supporters want? I feel that certain clubs prioritise finances over experiences and opportunities for their supporters in European football. I put Celtic into that category.
“Yeah, it’s a well-run business. You cannot fault anyone there when they post a profit at the end of the financial year. You cannot fault them for having £60m, £70m, £80m cash in the bank. That is perfect, that is how it should be.
“However, they’ve got to remember they’re in the entertainment business. Scottish football needs a Scottish team to have success on the European stage. It is Champions League or bust for Celtic as far as I’m concerned now. To be beaten by a team with the limited quality of LASK is unacceptable for a club of their size.
“Sorry, but Celtic Football Club is built on fear. They have a fear of failure. The strategy they have is that even when they don’t reach the Champions League league phase and have to go into the Europa League, they’ll be okay financially. Now, that’s basically fear.”
HAVE YOUR SAY – Join the Celtic conversation in our comments section below…
The post Celtic figures privately back Ian Joy as CBS pundit reveals behind-the-scenes messages appeared first on Celtic Shorts.