Celtic fan representative provides common sense on AGM chaos
Chair of Celtic Supporters Limited, Duncan Smillie, has called upon Hoops fans to behave respectfully at the crucial upcoming AGM to avoid a repeat of last year's disaster.
Last year's AGM was cut short after Ross Desmond gave a critical statement that was met with intense backlash, and that led to cluub officials calling the meeting to an early end.
That was the opposite of what Celtic fans needed, given how rarely they get to communicate with board members and ask questions of how the club is being run.
And amid an ongoing civil war between the fans and the board, fan representatives cannot afford o waste another opportunity at this year's AGM, which takes place on December 1.
Much has been made of the behaviour club officials at last year's AGM, but there probably hasn't been enough accountability from the supporters who crossed the line with their own behaviour, with both parties certainly sharing blame for how it all played out.
Celtic Supporters Limited chair Smillie has provided a more honest assessment, requesting better behaviour this time around. "He's (Dermot Desmond) not attending that. Whether he sends his son or not, I'm assuming that he's not going to be there," he began when speaking to the Daily Record.
“The way the AGM was conducted last year was appalling. It was unbecoming of Celtic and of their fans. And I think that there were no winners in the meeting that day.
“Irrespective of what you think of Peter Lawwell, he's a heavyweight… he chaired that meeting appallingly.
“And I think the behaviour of many Celtic fans in that room that day gave an absolute open goal for him to shut that meeting down. It played straight into their hands. I didn't like that. We get one opportunity a year as fans and shareholders to ask questions and that was shut down.
“That can't happen again. People have got to go to that meeting and behave in a certain way. If you don't respect the people that are sat behind the table at the meeting, respect where you are and do not give them an out on this again.”
It's nice to hear some common sense from a fan representative. As is often the case when two parties are at odds, we often get one side or the other and nothing in between. The more productive approach is for both parties to accept some responsibility and start working together to move forward. Throwing rocks from one side to the other just isn't going to help.