
It wasn’t long ago that Alejandro Balde was Barcelona’s first-choice left-back and under serious consideration to start for Spain. The 23-year-old started 21 league matches for Hansi Flick’s men last season. That return would have been higher had the youngster not succumbed to a couple of muscle injuries.
However, Balde was overlooked for Luis de la Fuente’s Spain squad for the 2026 World Cup. De la Fuente favoured Marc Cucurella and Alejandro Grimaldo. In the months since, Balde has struggled for minutes at Spotify Camp Nou.
Indeed, Flick has opted for Xavi Espart and Joao Cancelo as his first-choice full-backs. All four of Balde's outings this season have come off the bench, totalling 117 minutes. 60 of those came in the 2-1 Clasico defeat to Real Madrid having replaced Espart after just half an hour in the surprise home loss.
It’s clear, then, that Balde’s time in Barcelona is all but over. It’s a shame it didn’t work out for the Spaniard, who looked set to nail down the starting spot when he broke onto the scene in the 2022/23 season. As things stand, though, a move in January is required. And despite dropping down the pecking order at Barcelona, Balde won’t be short of suitors in the New Year.
Manchester United have previously been credited with an interest in the left-back as they seek to bolster at the back. Another left-back wasn’t necessarily a priority for United over the summer, with the central midfield the port of call. However, a left sided defender was also on the agenda, though an area they failed to bolster in the off-season.
Luke Shaw is first choice in the position, but his fitness issues are cause for concern. Having managed to remain available for the full 38 league matches last season, Shaw has already missed four of nine Premier League games for one reason or another.
Diogo Dalot, a right-back by trade, has been his primary deputy, yet it’s a short-term fix. Patrick Dorgu is a better option further forward, and has himself endured his own injury issues. It’s clear that United need to add a new left-back when the transfer window opens in two months’ time.
Balde an upgrade on Shaw?
Is Balde, though, the answer? Well, on paper, yes. Balde offers the necessary drive and speed down the left flank to help stretch opponents. Under-fire head coach Michael Carrick implements a 4-2-3-1 system, with the wingers cutting in from the relevant flanks. It leaves the space for the full-backs to exploit, though they do struggle to do so.
Shaw, for example, offers little in the way of beating a marker. The England international is completing 0.2 take ons per 90 in the Premier League this season. By comparison, Balde managed 1.1 per 90 for Barcelona in the 2025/26 La Liga campaign. Granted, the latter was featuring for a more forward-thinking Barca side that plays a more expansive style of play that is better suited to his skillset.

Saying that, he’d offer United a more attack-minded option down the left side, which has been found wanting in England’s top tier this term. The full-backs at Carrick’s disposal have contributed to just two league goals in the 2026/27 season.
Balde may have only registered two assists in La Liga last season, but created a notable 1.1 chances per 90. Given the importance of an aggressive, offensive full-back in the modern game, Balde would be a fine fit to take over as United’s first-choice left-back, in theory anyway.
Injury issues a concern
That’s largely because Balde has endured his fair share of stints on the sidelines in years gone by. While it doesn’t quite rival Shaw for absence, the former Southampton man expected to sit out the Champions League meeting with Roma this week, Balde is still a player who has succumbed to a number of muscle ailments in previous seasons.
In the 2021/22 season, Balde missed 18 games with an ankle injury. In the 2023/24 campaign, the left-back sat out 22 matches with a tendon rupture. It’s these muscle and impact injuries that have stunted his development. In turn, he loses the explosiveness that comes from bombarding up and down the left flank.
United already have one injury-prone left-back on the cards. They can ill-afford to add another to the books.
While he’d be a cut-price option to swell the defensive ranks, United need to really make sure they can get the best deal possible to replace Shaw at left-back. Bringing in a full-back who may occupy a spot in the physio room is hardly the best use of resources for a club that has struggled financially in recent years.
Provided he could remain injury-free, then United would be foolish to pass up the chance to land Balde. This isn’t a guarantee, however, and while his style of play would mean an improvement on Shaw at left-back, the previous fitness worries means the pursuit of the Barca defender would be a risk.
Given the pressure that comes with playing for United, it’s one that may not be worth taking.