livescore

What If Manchester City’s Prizes Go Elsewhere

Published:
Dan TraceyDan Tracey
Manchester City Have Won The FA Cup Four Times Since 2011
Manchester City Have Won The FA Cup Four Times Since 2011

Unless you have been living under a rock during this international break, you will be fully aware that Manchester City are the hottest topic in football. The Etihad outfit has been found guilty of all 115 charges that were put forward by the Premier League, with an appeal process now set to follow.

Nobody knows if the appeal will be successful or how long the next phase of wrangling between Manchester City and the Premier League will take, but that has not stopped the endless amount of conjecture over the past week.

A large part of that conjecture has been steeped in punishment, and if City are to have the book thrown at them, how heavy will that book actually be? Some are suggesting a substantial fine, but would that really put a dent in the blue half of Manchester’s coffers?

If the punishment is not to be financial, then points deductions are the next logical step. Do you hit City with a huge deficit to all but confirm relegation at the end of this season, or do you shave, say, 60 points off for the next three years and make them run the Premier League gauntlet?

There are so many avenues to go down, and that is before we even talk about all the prizes that the club have won. Not only during the nine-season spell in question by the Premier League but all the success that comes after.

It is not outside the realm of possibility that without City’s skullduggery over the period between 2009/10 and 2017/18, they would not then be placed in good stead for the litany of trophies that subsequently followed.

Therefore, if everything is on the table in terms of having to be handed back and retroactive prizes were handed out instead to City’s rivals, it begs the question as to what the roll of honours would actually look like.

First up, we can look at the eight Premier League titles that City have won in the Premier League era.

Season

Replacement

2011/12

Man United

2013/14

Liverpool

2017/18

Man United

2018/19

Liverpool

2020/21

Man United

2021/22

Liverpool

2022/23

Arsenal

2023/24

Arsenal

Those eight Premier League crowns are shared between three of City’s nearest rivals, and it is both Manchester United and Liverpool who would have profited the most. The Old Trafford and Anfield outfits would have added three titles each to their names.

Also, Mikel Arteta would have also picked up two more Premier League titles and, in doing so, would have created quite the dynasty in North London. Had Arsenal been handed the 2022/23 and 2023/24 crowns, they would have been champions in three of the past four seasons.

This redistribution would have also meant a change in the number of Premier League titles won across the competition’s history. Now the 34 separate champions would be split as follows:

Club

Winners

Manchester United

16

Arsenal

6

Chelsea

5

Liverpool

5

Blackburn Rovers

1

Leicester City

1

Manchester United would be clear with 16 Premier League titles to their name, just short of half of all the 34 on offer. The Old Trafford outfit would have earned 10 more than Arsenal in second, one more than Liverpool, who now join Chelsea on five titles.

Quite a different landscape to how it currently looks with all Manchester City’s Premier League titles intact:

Club

Winners

Manchester United

13

Manchester City

8

Chelsea

5

Arsenal

4

Liverpool

2

Blackburn Rovers

1

Leicester City

1

Of course, the redistribution of Premier League titles would also change the number of top-tier titles won by Manchester United and Liverpool. Their current tally of 20 each would subsequently be enhanced to 23 as the battle to be the all-time best in English football continues.

Then again, it is not just the Premier League where Manchester City could be airbrushed from history. There is also a multitude of knockout trophies that they have collected, none more so than the seven League Cups that they have won during the period in question.

If those seven were handed out to each of the losing finalists, the winners of the seasons would look like this:

Season

Replacement

2013/14

Sunderland

2015/16

Liverpool

2017/18

Arsenal

2018/19

Chelsea

2019/20

Aston Villa

2020/21

Tottenham

2025/26

Arsenal

Arsenal are collecting two more League Cups to their name after retrospectively being handed the trophy both last season and eight years before that in 2018. The quintet of Sunderland, Liverpool, Chelsea, Aston Villa and Tottenham also added an extra trophy to their name.

For the Black Cats in particular, their 2014 success would feel even sweeter. After already losing the 1985 final to Norwich, a retrospective win over Manchester City would signify their first-ever League Cup win.

Of course, it is not just League Cups that Manchester City have collected in excess, as there are also their four FA Cup wins to divide out, and by the same process, it would look as follows:

Season

Replacement

2010/11

Stoke City

2018/19

Watford

2022/23

Man United

2025/26

Chelsea

Good news for Tony Pulis as he would have upgraded his runner-up medal in 2011 to a winning edition instead. Stoke would be the first retroactive beneficiaries and would then be joined by a rather grateful Watford in 2019.

That was the season when the Hornets were mauled by City in the final. A 6-0 win for Pep Guardiola’s men would now be scratched from the record books, Watford supporters now breathing a sigh of relief.

Celebrations for both Stoke and Watford as they collect their first-ever FA Cup wins, a further addition to the trophy room for Manchester United and Chelsea as they pick up wins in 2023 and 2026 to take them to 14 (now joint-highest with Arsenal) and nine, respectively.

If City’s Premier League and FA Cup successes were retrospectively removed, their four Community Shield victories would also have to be reconsidered, while the same applies to their UEFA Super Cup and Club World Cup trophies following their Champions League triumph over Inter in 2023

26 trophies now passed on elsewhere, a summary that looks like this:

Club

City trophies inherited

Liverpool

5

Man United

5

Arsenal

4

Chelsea

4

Stoke City

1

Watford

1

Sunderland

1

Aston Villa

1

Tottenham

1

Inter Milan

1

Sevilla

1

Fluminense

1

TOTAL

26

Liverpool and Manchester United are the biggest overall beneficiaries, with five additional trophies each. The duo of London giants Arsenal and Chelsea scooping up four more prizes for themselves. All other clubs in the list picking up one.

Of course, this is purely a hypothetical exercise. There is no way of knowing what would actually have happened had City’s success not occurred in the first place. However, it does provide one rather stark illustration of just how much of football’s recent history has been shaped by a club that could potentially have it all to lose.

Discover more from LiveScore
Never miss an update. Add LiveScore as a preferred source on Google for the latest news and match predictions.
add preferred sourceAdd
NewsFootball NewsPremier League News
What If Manchester City’s Prizes Go Elsewhere