Mikel Arteta and the ‘inconvenient truth’ about Covid and Arsenal success
Would Mikel Arteta still be Arsenal manager if his lowest times had been in front of a massive Emirates crowd?
It’s food for thought. Send your views to theeditor@football365.com
The Arteta myth
Yeah, all well and good AB, Maidenhead. Unfortunately you’re overlooking the inconvenient truth that Arteta would never have reached so far as Phase 2 if the 2020-21 season wasn’t played in lockdown times. This phased rebuild is a myth and Arsenal lucked out.
Arteta is one of the greatest beneficiaries of the pandemic. If his early Arsenal sides were playing in a full Emirates, the famously impatient Arsenal fan noise and discontent would very quickly build to a crescendo, fan pressure would render Arteta’s position untenable and he’d be lucky to last a full season before he’d be out on his arse. Arsenal were that bad at the turn of the decade. They were possibly even more painful to watch and miserable than United are at present. Arteta looked much more likely to take Arsenal down than ever win them the title.
United and Pochettino won’t have such luxury. We won’t have the time or patience to implement a phased approach back to the top, particularly in the midst of a relegation scrap. Though if we do go down, if it meant a change in ownership and a total clear-the-decks reset, relegation would be a small price to pay. Dan in Worthing, I agree with every word. Lee, increasingly exasperated by United
…Sorry to burst the bubble, but there is no Arsenal blueprint. Certainly, if they hadn’t PGMOL’d their way to the title, it wouldn’t be something anyone would cite. It’s not that what they did was wrong, just that the end product is as much the result of luck; luck with injuries, form and referee decisions.
The truth of the matter, however, is that you need a sensible plan and the time/backing to implement it.
At United there is no real apparent plan, and certainly no time is afforded. Currently we have the incomplete product of at least 4 different and opposing plans. Following the old mantra of fail fast is great unless you fail at everything, in which case it just ends up as a death spiral.
Well here’s my solution: just fix the problems. What that means is:
1/ fix the glaring squad gaps
2/ fix the player profile issues (including mentality and lack of on pitch leadership)
3/ incrementally raise the floor.
There we go; three phases, if you will.
United still somehow have the luxury of being a desirable club with some good players. It doesn’t require a full Klopp/Arteta-style full new starting XI.
I’ve seen us being linked with some names that many fans have questioned. Players like Bassey. Are they elite or have a high ceiling? No, but yet they would immediately become our best CB in the short term, and would provide stability for Yoro and Heaven – our potential Saliba and Gabriel partnership – to grow next to. Add Toney and Ait Nouri or Balde and things are transformed.
The tragedy/hilarity of United’s decline is the sheer apparently-deliberate intent to always pick the wrong option. Can we just give one person some time and trust to fix things, even if just for a change? Badwolf
Arteta getting no credit for White supremacy
I’ve given the boy a lot of well deserved clog, and he wouldn’t have been anywhere near the England squad if I were in charge, but what a performance by Ben White. And that double save by Trafford near the end, wow. That was what Tuchel originally promised us – fast, physical, PL style football. Now do that in a final against that level of opposition. And win.
In other news, I see Croydon’s finest has taken some time out from supporting Reform to tell us “Arsenal’s mentality is rubbing off on others”. Yes Christopher, I deffo remember El Monotone giving young Master White loads of minutes and getting him flying down the wing scoring goals with a better first touch/finish than Gyokeres, I can absolutely see what you mean there.
Think you’ll find that’s what talented players freed from Mikel Actuary’s tyrannical yoke can do if properly coached and allowed to play with at least a suspicion of risk taking. RHT/TS x
(Yamal is going to be as nauseating as CR7, isn’t he)
How good were England?
As a Spain resident, this is an extra sweet victory. I didn’t even know the game was on Sunday till a couple of hours before, but luckily it was on terrestrial TV .
This is the blueprint for defense for England moving forward. White, Hall the fullbacks Ezri & Quansah and at last James Trafford.
We already had a good front six and did not miss Saka.
The manager took off the right players at the right time and we were the better team.
A memorable night and no living England fan would complain if the first lifted silverware of our lifetimes is the Nations League . Peter (whole team motm!), Andalucia
…’Trafford’s roll out led to the corner for Konsa’s goal.’
Well, that seals it then; Trafford is England’s new nr. 1. Can’t wait for his next roll-out. How many roll-out pre-pre-pre-pre-assists will he garner as goalkeeper for the future European and World Champions I wonder? Guy, Breda, Holland
Ending Spain’s streak
For England fans rightfully giddy over a Nations League win snapping Spain’s long unbeaten streak, just a reminder that this has happened before. In June of 2009, in another lesser international tournament (the Confederations Cup), Spain had a 35-match unbeaten run ended by…the USA. The coach was Bob Bradley.
That is all. Peter G, Pennsylvania, USA (always supporting England in the big tournaments)
Poch: Not all that
At risk of sounding a little like Paxman, I’m sorry but I’m going to be frightfully rude here to Phil in London regarding his reply to my assertion that this isn’t Klopp coming in at Liverpool, or Mourinho at Chelsea. Quite frankly, it really isn’t.
Have a look at the medals on the table. Have a look at the SUCCESS with unfashionable clubs.
There are levels to this.
Totally understand why Spurs fans love him. But you’ve got to place his work in the wider context. A lot of them seem to miss this very important point, and many get very crabby when it challenges their assumptions. Andy H, Swansea
Poch and his Spanish advantage
I read in wonderment at Gerrard’s theory about Pochettino’s Spanish language skills getting him the United job. You were being generous describing it as “left-field” when it’s not only batshit, it reflects the worst kind of simplistic, glib, PFM know-nothing banal ignorance that only the cossetted English punditocracy could display.
Of the four players he name-checked as supposedly benefitting from Pochettino speaking Spanish – and leaving aside the fact they all speak near-native English – two have Portuguese as their mother tongues and the other has French. It’s also worth nothing that Cunha (Spanish, German, Italian, French), Fernandes (Spanish, Italian, French) and Diallo (Italian) all speak other languages. I mean, Cunha speaks six for heaven’s sake. In fact, only two players – Martinez and Ugarte – in the current United first-team squad actually have Spanish as their first language. The mother tongue, other than English, with the most United players (seven) is French, so by Gerrard’s logic they should have got Deschamps in.
It’s actually really sad as much as anything else that Gerrard would even think this, let alone say it out loud. The only thing sadder is the fact that we’re such a monoglot nation that some of our most celebrated players – who have had the privilege to spend years in multinational dressing rooms surrounded by multilingual colleagues – express incredulity at something that is completely normal elsewhere in the world. Compare it with, say, Anthony Gordon or Trent Alexander-Arnold: players who consciously applied themselves to learning Spanish before going abroad so that they could turn up at Barcelona and Real Madrid and do their very first pressers in Spanish.
Anyway, the reason United appointed Pochettino is obvious: he is perceived as having the size of personality and depth of experience to actually be able to do a near-impossible job that has crushed others. They should clearly have gone for him when they appointed Ten Hag (which is what many United fans thought at the time). But his approach to youth, the kind of thrilling front-foot attacking football he wants to play, and the slight sense of romanticism he clearly has for the job in terms of commitment to a proper rebuilding project all imply that, if nothing else, he’s certainly a good fit – arguably the best fit of any post-Fergie manager – and, if he cannot do it, probably nobody can. Matt, Sheffield
…Just read the piece on Gerrard’s “left field” reason for Pochettino being that he speaks Spanish, and just wondered if I was the only one who noticed that none of the players he mentions are Spanish and 3 come from countries that don’t speak Spanish.
Cheers. Paul
Revelations
You can see why Romano is at the beating heart of transfer news. In ‘Man Utd: Romano reveals how many signings Pochettino will make in January’ you report Nostradamus as saying ‘I therefore expect at least one signing , but it could be even more. It could be two or more, so let’s see what happens.’
So in a nutshell, his revelation is: Man Utd won’t sign no one at all, but may sign any indeterminate number upwards from there.
Man’s a genius. Iain, Sunderland