Man Utd still paying the price for Ten Hag's transfer failure: €140m evaporates
Erik ten Hag was in charge at Manchester United from July 2022 through October 2024 and was given a free hand during that time to strengthen the squad at Old Trafford.
However, that transfer policy is now leaving the English giants with a significant financial hangover. The seven players brought in by the Dutch manager who are currently still under contract with the club have a combined Estimated Transfer Value (ETV) of €200 million - but nearly €340m was paid for them at the time.
It is evidence that Man Utd are still haunted by the mistakes of the past, even if that does not exonerate the new regime from blame for the club's current predicament. During the period when Ten Hag called the shots in the transfer market, the purse strings were very loose indeed.
In his debut season in 2022/23, the club spent €242.5m on new signings, after which another €212.7m was squandered in the 2023/24 season. In the summer of the 2024/25 season, just a few months before his dismissal in October 2024, Man Utd spent a further €214.5m on fresh blood.
It did not bring the English club much success. Two years after Ten Hag's departure, and three permanent head coaches later, the Old Trafford outfit are still in the doldrums.
A midfield mess
The hardest financial blows have been dealt to Man Utd in midfield, where Mason Mount and Manuel Ugarte have seen a significant drop in value. When Mount was signed from Chelsea in July 2023, the club paid €67.7 million for the Englishman.
However, the most recent figures from this month show that the ETV of the 27-year-old, who still has a contract until 2028, has since dropped to €22.4m. That is a decline of no less than €45.3m, representing a loss of 66.9% compared to the amount paid for him.
In Ugarte's case, more than half of the original transfer fee has also gone up in smoke, based on his ETV. The Uruguayan was brought to Man Utd for €50m, but his current ETV remains stuck at €24.4m. This represents a drop in value of €25.6m ( or 51.2%).
Other flops
Looking at the other Ten Hag signings still at Man Utd, we see that Lisandro Martinez has cost the most money in absolute terms regarding a loss in value.
The Argentine defender left Ajax in July 2022 for a fee of €57.37m, but now has an ETV of only €28m (a decrease of €29.37m). Martinez is under contract at Old Trafford until the end of the current season, although the club does have an option to extend that agreement by 12 months.
Matthijs de Ligt and Joshua Zirkzee, who both arrived in England in the summer of 2024, have also endured a significant decline over more than €18m each.
De Ligt was acquired from Bayern Munich in August 2024 for €45m and signed a contract until 2029. The 27-year-old central defender required lengthy rehabilitation following back surgery and sees his ETV drop in the latest update from €38.1m in October to €26.9m (a €18.1m reduction compared to his 2024 purchase price).
Perennial benchwarmer Zirkzee made the move from Bologna to England in July 2024 for €42.5m and now has an ETV of just €24.3m (a drop of 18.2m). He has played just 3,000 minutes in his two-and-a-half years at Man Utd.
Damage limitation from Mazraoui and Yoro
Fortunately for Manchester United, not every player from Erik ten Hag's stable has been a complete financial disaster. Noussair Mazraoui arrived from Bayern Munich in August 2024 for €15 million and is the only one of the seven remaining signings currently worth more than his purchase price.
The 29-year-old right-back, who has a contract until 2028 and is reportedly on AC Milan's shortlist for the January transfer window, currently has an ETV of €16.4m (a €1.4m or 9.3% gain).
The damage is also relatively limited for Leny Yoro. The French central defender was snapped up from Lille in July 2024 for €62m and has become a regular starter in recent weeks. His ETV currently stands at 58.3m (a minor decrease of €3.7m or 6%).
Taking stock of the seven remaining players, their combined transfer value has plummeted by no less than €138.87m. That is a drop in value of 40.9% compared to the transfer fees paid at the time.
And, of course, things would look even worse if we included the Ten Hag signings that have already departed. Antony cost €95m and was sold for €25m, Rasmus Hojlund joined for €79.8m and left for €44.8m.
Casemiro, a €70m signing from Real Madrid, departed on a free transfer this summer, as did €15m recruit Tyrell Malacia. €50.2m goalkeeper Andre Onana, not currently at the club, is expected to be sold for just €10m-€20m next year, following his second loan at Trabzonspor.
Similarly, forgotten shot-stopper Altay Bayindir is unlikely to offer much return on investment on his €5m fee considering that he can't even get minutes at Celta Vigo.
In addition to permanent transfers, the Ten Hag regime also spent sizeable loan fees on Sofyan Amrabat (€10m), Wout Weghorst (€2.83m) and Martin Dubravka (€2.3m), only for these players to eventually be sent back to their parent clubs.