Assessing Newcastle’s season so far: What has worked, what needs to improve, and rest of the season predictions
Did we all get too ahead of ourselves? Were the last five years simply a mirage of what Newcastle United could be? Are we now back to that familiar mediocrity synonymous with generations prior on Tyneside? Maybe.
Well, not quite, but that doesn’t mean to say that things are absolutely ideal at St James’ Park at present. Ten games into the Premier League season and Matthias Jaissle’s Magpies sit very much in mid-table on 12 points.
That was the same tally at this stage of the season last year, albeit having played several favourable games this time around without extracting maximum points.
So where exactly are we with Newcastle 2.0?
The story of the season so far
Despite some of the reservations in pre-season and concerns that new head coach Matthias Jaissle was being thrown in at the deep end, Newcastle began the campaign well.
They were excellent against Liverpool on the opening day, buoyed by the spirit of Kevin Keegan and the animosity towards the returning Alexander Isak.
Only a cruel, late blow inflicted from the penalty spot by Dominik Szoboszlai denied them three points. An away win over Spurs came the following week, before an inspired comeback draw against Bournemouth saw things continue to look up.
Then came a hammering at Elland Road and the doubts returned.
Admittedly, that was followed by a good performance against Hull for 60 minutes, before a final half an hour that saw Newcastle cling on for victory.
The doubts grew stronger.
A trip to newly promoted Coventry seemed like an ideal chance for Newcastle to assert themselves and win again. Instead, the horror of another 4-1 loss, despite creating enough chances to have made the scoreline rather different, was met with anguish and further questions.
Villa came and won at St James’ Park, and despite some improvements in the second half of a win over Palace, the lack of any cohesion in the first half still left many scratching their heads.
Since then, Newcastle have lost twice to Everton in the space of four days, including one defeat that dumped them out of the Carabao Cup at the earliest stage since 2021, before some very small green shoots appeared in a draw with Fulham.
What has worked?
Ultimately, not a great deal.
There have been moments of good – the second halves against Liverpool, Spurs and Palace spring to mind, as well as the first hour or so against Hull. In those matches, Newcastle did look like they had pace, purpose and poise, but those performances have been all too few and far between.
In terms of the playing staff, the standout has undoubtedly been Lewis Hall. In a squad that would appear to be lacking quality in various areas, he has shown why he is the best left-back in the country.
A special mention should also go to young Sean Steur, who, despite his age, looks like a player beyond his years. His performance against Hull was masterful.
Also to Amar Dedić, who, despite a couple of errors, has taken to the Premier League like a duck to water.
What needs to improve?
At their worst this season, Newcastle have lacked structure, identity and, at times, the concept of an overall game plan. Their midfield has often been too spread out, allowing opponents to play through them at will.
They need to be much harder to break down, less prone to giving the ball away in all areas of the pitch and, for goodness’ sake, stop hoofing it long to no one.
At times, it really has been exasperating to watch, to the extent that comparisons have been made to certain managers during the Mike Ashley era.
Manager verdict
Matthias Jaissle’s no-nonsense, German efficiency in his early days on Tyneside won over large sections of the fanbase.
Football is, though, a results business, and several of Newcastle’s results have been impossible to defend.
Jaissle has plenty of charisma on the touchline, but are his messages getting through to his players? Reports of confusion within the squad over what they are being asked to do would suggest not entirely.
He needs to demonstrate that he can set his team up for the demands of the Premier League and, when things are not working, be pragmatic and adapt.
In press conferences, he has actually become more open and warm as the situation has become more difficult. Hopefully, things now begin to heat up on the pitch.
What do they need to do in January?
There are two positions that are in desperate need of strengthening.
The first is striker. Will Osula has good attributes and definitely has a place in the squad, but Newcastle cannot continue to rely on him and Yoane Wissa to provide the goals.
A target man who plays with his back to goal could work, as long as he has runners going beyond him.
The second is a number 10.
Matthias Jaissle’s favoured 4-2-3-1 formation requires a number 10. There is just one problem: Newcastle currently do not have one.
Until he does, Jaissle should adapt to suit the players he currently has, play a three-man midfield and stop shoehorning either Joe Willock or Yoane Wissa into a role neither is suited to.
Predictions for the rest of the season
A lot probably depends on January and what additions, if any, they make. That could be the making of Newcastle’s season.
At present, they are destined for that unpleasant void between the European places and the relegation zone, where finishing anywhere between seventh and 17th seems possible.
If I were to predict, with things the way they are now, I’d say a rather uninspiring 13th.
Let’s hope sporting director Ross Wilson has something up his sleeve in the new year for his head coach.