Assessing Man City’s season so far: What has worked, what needs to improve, and rest of the season predictions
Enzo Maresca’s Manchester City tenure got off to a flying start, although that has since threatened to be a false dawn.
The Italian became the first manager in Premier League history to win his first seven matches in charge of a new club. Their early-season form saw City race to the top of the table, and they enjoyed a similarly faultless record in cup competitions – barring a narrow defeat to European champions PSG.
However, things were far from perfect during that run. They scraped across the line in a number of chaotic encounters, with defensive vulnerabilities a notable concern.
City have now succumbed to three consecutive league defeats, leaving Maresca’s honeymoon period very much in the rear-view mirror. Aston Villa, Brighton and, most recently, Nottingham Forest all overcame City by exposing their weaknesses in transition.
Still, the biggest story of City’s season so far has taken place away from the pitch. The club and the wider footballing world were rocked by the independent commission’s findings that City were guilty of an overwhelming majority of the Premier League’s 115 charges for breaches of financial rules.
Nevertheless, with the appeal process underway, City are continuing to chase trophies and Maresca must find a way to resurrect their recent form.
What has worked?
Rodri had been the cornerstone of City’s triumphs in their final seasons under Pep Guardiola, meaning his summer departure left huge shoes to fill. Elliot Anderson arrived for £116 million and has shown all the signs of being a suitable successor to the Spaniard. The 24-year-old has regularly impressed and already looks like a contender for signing of the season.
Another strength of City this season has been their attack. Despite a recent drop-off, they are still ranked second for goals scored in the Premier League. The Blues have also created more xG than their opponents in every fixture bar one this season – their 5-3 win over Sunderland.
Although actual goals are, of course, far more important, the statistics do demonstrate that Maresca’s side are continuing to create chances at a plentiful rate – albeit with a need to be more clinical.
What needs to improve?
Many of City’s current vulnerabilities are rooted in Maresca’s system. In possession, the Italian likes to push one of his full-backs high into the forward line, as well as one of his central midfielders. This leaves Anderson isolated at the base of midfield and, while he has been excellent, he is being tasked with more work than is realistically possible to accomplish.
Also, as the sole man connecting the play, the 24-year-old will naturally drift into wide areas, leaving City utterly exposed if possession is lost.
At Maresca’s request, Enzo Fernandez was pursued and acquired this summer for a joint-British record fee of £125 million. Yet it is a move that has simply not worked so far. The Argentina international lacks the defensive ability to play as a six and does not have the attacking qualities to play as a ten when compared to other options such as Rayan Cherki and Phil Foden.
As such, Fernandez has regularly been deployed alongside Anderson and Cherki in midfield. However, as he pushes forward in accordance with the manager’s instructions, he lacks the athleticism to provide defensive support. Presently, Fernandez offers little going forward while hampering the side defensively, and the team may well be more balanced and stronger without him in it.
City have also lacked balance at the back. Ruben Dias and Marc Guehi, while the more experienced options at centre-back, have become increasingly error-prone.
Abdukodir Khusanov’s pace provides a potential fix to City’s defensive vulnerabilities. However, albeit partly due to Matheus Nunes’ injury, the Uzbekistan international has regularly been fielded at right-back – a position where he never quite looks comfortable.
Josko Gvardiol is another option at centre-half, although he has played almost exclusively at left-back this season. This, too, has been partly forced by Nico O’Reilly’s injury struggles. Maresca pushes Gvardiol all the way into the forward line in possession, leading to the Croatian regularly being caught out at the other end of the pitch.
A further problem has presented itself in the form of Gianluigi Donnarumma. The experienced goalkeeper has let in numerous soft goals this season, amplifying the side’s wider issues.
Manager verdict
While Maresca has not been in his post for long, he has shown signs of being a shrewd appointment as Guardiola’s successor. However, his tenure could soon reach a critical juncture.
So far, he has remained stubborn in his system and, given his track record at previous clubs, one would expect the Italian to remain so.
With some minor tweaks, things could click and City could return to their imperious early-season form. Conversely, if their issues intensify, then Maresca’s loyalty to his tactical approach will be seriously tested. If City’s defensive vulnerabilities are not resolved, the Italian may eventually have to abandon his system.
The Fernandez conundrum could form another thorn in Maresca’s side. The manager was the driving force behind the club’s record signing and will undoubtedly feel pressure to make the move work. He trusts the midfielder completely, but could that be his downfall?
Many fans are already calling to see Ayyoub Bouaddi replace Fernandez in the line-up.
What do they need to do in January?
There is one major glaring hole in City’s squad – and it is not a new one. The club’s lack of depth at full-back has persisted for close to a decade at this stage.
With Rico Lewis not trusted, the options at right-back are converted midfielder Nunes and centre-back Khusanov. Meanwhile, with Rayan Aït-Nouri not favoured, the options at left-back are converted midfielder O’Reilly and centre-back Gvardiol.
Predictions for the rest of the season
With the threat of a points deduction on an unprecedented scale and the chaos that would bring, it is nigh-on impossible to predict what the rest of the season will hold.
What remains certain, at least for now, is that City possess an exceptional squad, probably the strongest attack in the country, and should be a force to be reckoned with.
At their current pace, City are on track to tally 80 Premier League points – two more than they did last term. While that may not be enough to claim the title, they would certainly expect to be in the mix with such a figure.
Even if the title is out of reach in his first season, Maresca will still be eyeing silverware. Having reached the quarter-finals, the Blues are now favourites to go all the way in the Carabao Cup.
After claiming a domestic double last season, they could fancy their chances of repeating that feat with the FA Cup too. Their competitive clash with PSG suggests that a deep European run is more than possible as well.