The Jan Paul van Hecke and Luka Vuskovic discourse is getting way out of hand
I don’t know about you, folks, but I’m absolutely sick of the discourse surrounding Jan Paul van Hecke and Luka Vušković.
While the latter continues to be regarded as the finest defender since Franz Beckenbauer, Van Hecke’s work since joining the Lilywhites has become incredibly underrated.
Spurs essentially swapped Van Hecke for Vušković in the summer. Those without an intimate knowledge of the Croatian centre-back’s situation have pointed the Lilywhites out to be be mad, given Vušković’s reputation as one of the most talented young defenders on the continent.
While it's unclear whether the defender pushed for a move this summer, he rarely gave the impression that he saw his long-term future with Tottenham. During his loan spell at Hamburg, there was merely talk of the defender’s next move, rather than what he could achieve in N17.
His agent talked up interest from Europe’s elite while Tottenham toiled, and although survival was confirmed with Roberto De Zerbi at the helm, it was decided by all parties that a departure would be best in the summer. With Van Hecke arriving, Vušković wasn’t immediately in De Zerbi’s plans, so Spurs shipped the teenager to Brighton & Hove Albion for a club-record £46 million.
And given how fashionable it is to smear the north Londoners, this de facto exchange has been discussed in wildly hyperbolic terms.
Van Hecke/Vušković debate has evolved into hyperbolic mess
Brighton have dazzled at the start of the new season, and it’d be a bare faced lie to suggest that Vušković hasn’t been impressive on the south coast. He looks the part, but it seems as if the majority are happy to sweep any distinct flaws under the rug.
If you watch the sport with your eyes and not through the lens of Fantasy Football, it can be discerned as to why De Zerbi perhaps wasn’t fully sold. He turns slowly, and can often appear flat-footed in one-on-one situations. I watched on as Croatia succumbed to a historic 7-0 defeat to England in October, and was taken aback by Vušković’s lack of defensive fundamentals. I appreciate that this was a bad day for all involved, but it was the second time this year that Vušković has struggled mightily against the Three Lions.
Van Hecke, meanwhile, is far from a utopian defender. I can’t say I’m a huge fan of his work defensively. He reminds me of Cristian Romero, but without the superb sense of timing. Nevertheless, he is an outstanding ball player—and that matters in this day and age, especially for De Zerbi.
When you take a look at the numbers, it’s quite remarkable that folk like the infamous Raj Chohan have gone as far as to suggest the Vušković/Van Hecke exchange will go down as “one of the worst pieces of transfer business in football history.” Now, this bloke likes to paint himself as some sort of prophet, and loves to reinforce this idea by reposting any historic tweets that age handsomely.
He also said Thomas Frank would have Tottenham competing in the top five in no time, yet he curiously wasn’t plastering that take all over his timeline when Frank left the club in February after eight months of misery.
Anyway, back to the debate. You can directly compare to two defenders on MARKSTATS, which highlights Van Hecke’s superiority in possession. The Dutchman averages more progressive passes (6.79 to 3.59) and progressive carries (3.12 to 1.16) per 90 minutes, and is more efficient and progressing the ball up the pitch, per Mark’s ‘progression efficiency’ metric.
Defensively, Van Hecke also averages more high defensive actions (0.64 to 0.56) and boasts a far superior tackle success rate (75% to 57.14%). Vušković is undeniably better in the air, with the Croat winning 71.93% of his aerial duels compared to Van Hecke’s 58.62%.
I know that data alone cannot paint a fair picture of a defender’s competence, but the numbers do highlight the silliness of this debate. Van Hecke has been pretty good for Spurs despite the volatility, while Vušković has also settled in nicely for an excellent Brighton team.
Instead of committing to idiotically exaggerated takes for the sake of engagement, perhaps we could just accept that the faux exchange has worked out for everyone involved.