Alejandro Garnacho the new Harvey Elliott? Eight pointless loan moves
Who will be this season’s Harvey Elliott?
Every year, there are loan deals that get signed off with the best of intentions from all parties – to get fringe players more minutes, either building them up for reintegration or putting them in the shop window for a permanent departure – but sometimes they go awry.
Last season it was Elliott most notably sat twiddling his thumbs while on loan at Aston Villa from Liverpool. Villa’s reluctance to trigger a permanent transfer left him stuck on the sidelines – and he wasn’t the only one enduring a pointless loan.
We’re still in the relatively early days of this season, but not for much longer. Soon, some underused loanees might be starting to worry they’ll be in the class of 2026/27 for pointless loans – especially when January could give them a chance to escape.
Here are eight loan moves this season involving Premier League clubs already looking like they might be a waste of everyone’s time.
Alejandro Garnacho (Aston Villa, on loan from Chelsea)
Aston Villa should probably just stop signing castaways on loan from the kind of elite Premier League clubs they’re trying – and seemingly succeeding – to establish themselves alongside.
You’d think they’d have learnt their lesson from the Elliott fiasco last season. But once again, they agreed to have an obligation to buy their loan signing depending on appearance criteria. Silly Villa.
Garnacho is yet to start a game for Villa in any competition. He’s played seven times off the bench, for a total of 95 minutes. For three of their past four league matches, he’s not even been in the squad.
There was a sense in the summer that if Unai Emery wanted Garnacho, it must be for good reason. You see how he’s taken Nicolas Jackson up a level after signing him and wonder if that’s what Villa thought he could do with Garnacho. But it just isn’t happening.
Unlike Elliott, Garnacho didn’t play for his parent club in the same season as he completed his loan move, so there might be a chance for a January get-out. If not, and should things fail to improve for him at Villa Park, he risks being left on the fringes.
Still only 22, Garnacho shouldn’t be a lost cause. But he was an expensive mistake for Chelsea and is a luxury rotting on the bench for Villa.
Promise David (Brighton, on loan from Union SG)
Sometimes it’s not what you know, it’s who you know. Brighton always had an edge on any rivals trying to sign David thanks to Tony Bloom’s involvement with Union Saint-Gilloise, where the striker averaged a goal every other game across 82 appearances.
Brighton know a thing or two about savvy moves and you’d have been forgiven for thinking this was another. But David hasn’t been given a chance to live up to his promise (sorry) at the Amex.
His four appearances for Brighton so far have all been as a substitute. Only two were in the Premier League, the most recent of which was in their first game in September.
Brighton are already well stocked up front. They’ve even got European involvement this season in the Conference League, but even that hasn’t been a platform for David to be rotated into the line-up.
He’s another case of a player being held back because of an obligatory purchase clause; Brighton will have to spend more than £20m on him if he plays in a certain number of games, but they’re being patient/reluctant so far.
Altay Bayindir (Celta de Vigo, on loan from Manchester United)
Not really United’s problem, this. Bayindir was never someone they were going to sell for tons of money, even if he did well out on loan. It simply made sense to clear space by sending him away.
But from his own perspective, the goalkeeper might have hoped not to be a back-up for Celta de Vigo after being a back-up for United for three years.
Ionut Radu remains Celta’s regular starter, with Bayindir’s only appearance so far being in a 5-0 Copa del Rey win over Salamanca. He’s not even been given a chance in the Europa League.
Trading one back-up role for another… bit pointless, innit?
Robinio Vaz (Hull City, on loan from Roma)
This time last year, Vaz was beginning to establish himself as a prospect up front for Marseille. But the two moves he’s made in 2026 have been ill-informed at best.
Roma bought him in January for €25m, but he was always going to play second fiddle to Donyell Malen. So they shipped him off to Hull for a season-long loan.
Trouble is, Hull signed every man and his dog this summer. Vaz has been crowded out by the competition and is yet to start a Premier League match. He had to drop down to play an under-21s game earlier this month.
Other than his hour-long cameo as a starter in the EFL Cup against Sunderland, his longest appearance for Hull so far has lasted just 22 minutes.
His parent club, who probably overpaid for him in the first place, must be worried he’s devaluing. Hull are doing fairly fine without him featuring too prominently, so don’t have much reason to change his place in their hierarchy just yet.
Jean-Matteo Bahoya (Leeds United, on loan from Eintracht Frankfurt)
Bahoya has played three times for Leeds so far. All three appearances have been as a substitute, with a pitiful amount of time on the pitch. One, four and six minutes precisely.
He wasn’t even included in Leeds’ squad at all for their last game before the international break.
“He needs to add a bit of physicality to his game,” Daniel Farke has offered. “He needs to improve his decision making, his finishing, and all. There are several aspects in the game that he needs to improve, and we want to do this.”
But use Bahoya too much and Leeds will be obliged to pay more than £25m to sign him permanently. Maybe that’s why they’ve kept the brakes on.
Evann Guessand (Crystal Palace, on loan from Aston Villa)
Palace weren’t convinced about signing Guessand permanently after he finished last season on loan there from Aston Villa, so proceeded to… sign him on loan from Aston Villa again.
The fact he hasn’t started a Premier League game since and hasn’t appeared since August except for in the EFL Cup against Fulham suggests their intentions around a permanent transfer remain unchanged.
Pierre Sage left Guessand out of his Europa League squad, so only ended up giving the French forward three appearances.
Guessand can only hope Sage’s successor, expected to be Thomas Frank, thinks more highly of him. Right now, it just looks like a case of delaying the inevitable, with Villa set to find a fresh solution for Guessand in 2027.
Souza (Porto, on loan from Tottenham)
Was Souza’s move to Spurs in January a waste of time to start with? He’s young, so you can never say for certain, but it might have been.
The long-term plan, which was so obviously a long-term plan, was always to sign Andy Robertson for the left-back berth. It took until the summer for Spurs to do so, but by then, Souza had been in England for half a year without making much impact.
Porto was an intriguing choice of destination for his next step. Plenty of Brazilians have flourished there before, but it’s a big club with high expectations and not necessarily an easy route into the first team for someone like Souza.
Lo and behold, he’s yet to start in either the league or the Champions League. Things might be starting to get better, though, as he made his first start in the cup towards the end of October and then got a full half of action on his league debut, but it’s been a slow start for the 20-year-old.
Harvey Elliott (Valencia, on loan from Liverpool)
What if this season’s Harvey Elliott is Harvey Elliott?
Look, it’s not going quite as badly as his Villa loan; he’s only 25 minutes away from surpassing his gametime from that ill-fated spell. But all the minutes he’s amassed in La Liga so far for Valencia have been from the bench.
This could have been the move he needed to break free and put the past behind him. But he got sent off on his sixth league appearance in a sign that things may be unravelling further.
He did get a goal in the Copa del Rey, but it was only against Tavernes, who usually play in the sixth tier of Spanish football.
Having taken the number 10 shirt, Elliott would have expected to play more often for Valencia. Perhaps they’re just being patient with him after so much time on the sidelines last season.
But with no option or obligation for Valencia to buy him, he could easily rock back up at Liverpool next summer, two years after they thought they’d shifted him for good. If that’s not a waste of time, we don’t know what is.