livescore
3 things we learned from Gotham FC's semifinal loss to the Kansas City Current

3 things we learned from Gotham FC's semifinal loss to the Kansas City Current

Michael Cardamone
Skyscraper Blues
Michael Cardamone

It was not the ending fans had hoped for. NJ/NY Gotham FC will not defend their NWSL Championship crown, as they were eliminated by the Kansas City Current with a score of 2-1. This result means a rematch of the 2025 Championship against the Washington Spirit, this time in D.C., will not become a reality.

This marks Gotham FC's first official NWSL playoff loss under head coach Juan Carlos Amorós in his fourth season and 10th playoff match at the club. Their elimination at the hands of Washington in the 2024 semifinals officially goes down as a draw because the match went to penalty kicks.

A beautiful free kick from Croix Bethune was answered in the second by another own goal forced by a Gotham cross, their second in two playoff games. But a Haley Hopkins banger off the crossbar in the 89th minute ultimately was enough for the Current to book their ticket to next Saturday's Championship Game against the Spirit.

This result sends Gotham FC into what will be an important offseason. Not just when it comes to finding ways to improve the club, but also because they have plenty of high-profile players without contracts for 2027. Before then, what did we learn from the loss?

Gotham FC needs to shoot to score

Two games, zero shots on goal. Both of Gotham FC's goals in the postseason came from own goals. Attacking struggles are not a new thing for the Bats under Amorós; they had the second-fewest goals scored amongst 2026 playoff teams, and were third-to-last and last amongst playoff teams in their two championship-winning seasons of 2025 and 2023, respectively.

The struggles continued into the playoffs with just 14 goals in 10 total NWSL playoff games. Despite these struggles being ever-present and evident for everyone to see, it is almost hard to criticize them because of their success under Amorós. After all, no other team has won more playoff games or overall trophies since he took over the NJ/NY side.

It became a very easy thing to brush aside because they out-defend their goal-scoring issues. But it finally caught up to them today as KC's late winner was just too much for them to overcome. And the players and coaching staff know these things; it is just a matter of whether or not they can come up with a solution.

Injuries were a killer

Losing key players like Bruninha, Jordynn Dudley, and Emily Sonnett to season-ending injuries, combined with other key players like Jaelin Howell and Rose Lavelle clearly not at 100%, proved too much for Gotham to fully overcome. Players like Midge Purce, Mandy Freeman, and Savannah McCaskill played admirably and did their best to fill those holes, but it seems like one too many injuries for the team to overcome.

A lot like the lack of attacking potency, overcoming a laundry list of injuries was something past Gotham teams were able to do. However, like the lack of attacking potency, this came back to bite them this time.

The Bats have, in recent years, seemingly revamped their approach to how they handle injured players. It seemed like Purce's ACL tear at the beginning of the 2024 season was a catalyst for these changes, which have led to a much more measured, careful approach to the return-to-play process for these injured players.

While this change certainly helped, it wasn't enough to keep up with the list of injuries that seemingly kept growing and growing as the season progressed. Part of that might be luck, but also Gotham's longer-than-usual season that saw them begin in January in London certainly played a role in these injuries piling up as well.

It was still a successful season for Gotham FC

It is never easy to end a season with a loss, especially a last-minute loss like this one. But it is important to remember that Gotham did manage to win their first Challenge Cup and NWSL Shield in club history. This means that even with them not able to defend their NWSL Championship from last year, they will still walk away from 2026 with more silverware than any other team in NWSL.

And while that may sound and feel like coping after a tough loss, which it kind of is, it is also kind of the right way to look at things in 2026. American sports fans tend to only care about the playoffs as the ultimate goal for what defines what is a successful or unsuccessful season.

But with the NWSL moving in a more international direction when it comes to having multiple competitions and opportunities to win silverware, the volume of trophies, depending on what those trophies are, may end up mattering more than who lifts the last one in November.

Add to that the fact that this was the longest season in NWSL history at 30 games; this is arguably the most impressive Shield win in league history. There were also plenty of quality teams, including the Current, Spirit, San Diego Wave FC, and Angel City FC. It was a tough slog through the 30+ games that Gotham FC went through this season in all competitions, and even with them missing out on this last one, it is still a season the club can be proud of.

NewsFootball NewsMore Football News
3 things we learned from Gotham FC's semifinal loss to the Kansas City Current