A USMNT Fan's Guide to the 2026 MLS Cup Playoffs (Eastern Conference First Round Edition)
MLS' Eastern Conference playoffs will begin in their entirety this weekend with four first-round series. After nailing my prediction for the Eastern Conference Wild Card, let's see if I can keep my strong analytical start to these MLS Cup Playoffs alive. Here are my predictions for the Eastern Conference side of the MLS Cup Playoffs' first round.
#1 Nashville SC vs #9 FC Cincinnati
Nashville is the clear favorite after a record-setting campaign. But not so fast. Each of the last two record-setting clubs with regard to regular-season point totals was eliminated upon entry to the MLS Cup Playoffs. The last club to set the points record and win MLS Cup was the 2017 edition of Toronto FC.
For Nashville, it will be a question of whether they can keep Cincinnati at arm's length or if the Orange and Blue are truly capable of keeping pace. Among the league's many metrics, many of which have the two sides separated by a marginal amount. Individually, the battles might not be as close. This is especially true with backup USMNT goalie Brian Schwake, who has easily been the best at his position this season.
This series should be closer than the regular season series, which went Nashville's way on a 6-0 aggregate scoreline. Maybe we get a competitive game, or maybe there's a penalty shootout. Even if one or both scenarios come to pass, Nashville should be able to hold off whatever Cincinnati throws their way and advance to the quarterfinals.
The pick: Nashville SC advances in two games
#2 Inter Miami vs #7 Columbus Crew
Inter Miami might not be the top seed in this year's MLS Cup Playoffs, but they are once again the most complete team in the tournament with Lionel Messi and Luis Suarez. That said, the Columbus Crew have won each of their last six MLS contests.
Miami has superstars but lacks high-end American talent. The Crew, meanwhile, features goalie Patrick Schulte and midfielder Sean Zawadzki, who has one USMNT cap. But mostly they rely on Taha Habroune and Gonzalo Tapia when it comes to matching their opponent's scoring.
I could see the Crew pulling off the upset; even if they don't, they should be able to get this series to a decisive third game. But it's very hard to go against this Inter Miami side, which has beaten the odds time and time again since Messi's arrival.
Prediction: Inter Miami wins in three games
#3 New England Revolution vs #6 Philadelphia Union
The Philadelphia Union completed a miraculous mid-season turnaround to qualify for the MLS Cup Playoffs. The way the bracket is set up, it might not end with just a postseason berth. The momentum is firmly behind the Union
USMNT wunderkind Cavan Sullivan was arguably the catalyst for the team's turnaround. He gives them enough goalscoring up and down the pitch to make the Revs think twice about a forward-focused game plan. The Union also has Neil Pierre, the 19-year-old center-back fresh off playing 45 minutes in the Nations League. Of course, the Revs counter with longtime goalie Matt Turner, as well as new USMNT additions Brooklyn Raines and Peyton Miller, who are big reasons why New England is favored.
If there is going to be a first-round upset in the East, this is where it's going to happen. It won't be a sweep, but I think the Union can do just enough on the offensive side of the ball to win a pair of games by a 2-1 or even a 3-1 margin.
Prediction: Philadelphia Union wins in three games
#4 Chicago Fire vs #5 Charlotte FC
This is a series that is going to be decided by goalkeeper Chris Brady. I'm not discounting the fact that Chicago has one of the best goalscorers in the modern game, Robert Lewandowski, and that, if required, they could score their way to a first-round victory. But it really doesn't feel like Chicago has done enough to prove they're part of the top tier of the Eastern Conference.
But if Charlotte can play defense during this series, they might be able to cancel out that advantage. After all, former USMNT captain Tim Ream anchors the Charlotte defense. Luca de la Torre is also a key part of the Charlotte midfield.
Chicago has the head-to-head advantage, having won both of their meetings with Charlotte. There is a catch: both games were decided by one goal. The first saw the Fire rally from an early 1-0 deficit, while the second was decided by an own goal. This series essentially feels like a coin flip, but Charlotte feels like the slightly more appealing pick overall.