Bayern Munich face a major dilemma as a pressing question resurfaces over Alphonso Davies
Alphonso Davies' agonising injury ordeal has taken another turn. The left-back is sidelined for Bayern Munich again, and at a particularly bad time.
More than 600 days after his last start for Canada, Alphonso Davies returned to the national team's starting line-up on Saturday. Six minutes later, his much-celebrated comeback was over. The 26-year-old slipped awkwardly without any contact from an opponent and left the pitch shortly afterwards, shaking his head.
Assistant coach Mauro Biello and the association initially described it, somewhat cryptically, as a "lower-body injury". The diagnosis has since emerged: Davies has suffered another thigh muscle tear. He will "be unavailable for the time being", the German record champions said cautiously on Monday. Given Davies' injury history, he is expected to be out for weeks. A return before December would be a surprise. He may not play again until after the winter break.
Bayern face an enforced absence at a bad time on several fronts. It also revives a pressing question.
Alphonso Davies was in top form and kept Nathaniel Brown in check
Davies has been producing top performances for Bayern again since the autumn. Just weeks after Nathaniel Brown's arrival, the lightning-quick fan favourite showed why he is among the club's highest earners. He kept the new signing out of the left-back spot and won back his regular starting place.
Before the international break, Davies also impressed one position further forward as a stand-in for Luis Diaz against Arsenal and Atletico Madrid, and for parts of the game against Borussia Dortmund. Bayern had not signed a back-up for Diaz in the summer, partly because Davies is a natural left winger. The Colombian, who is also unlikely to return against 1. FC Köln on Friday, had himself asked for a signing to ease his workload.
With Serge Gnabry (a serious thigh injury) and Ismael Saibari (a torn syndesmosis ligament) still sidelined for some time, Brown may have to help out in attack again, as he did at the start of the season. Jamal Musiala is close to returning to the squad but is unlikely to be ready to start. That leaves Konrad Laimer or the recently out-of-form Josip Stanisic to fill in at left-back.
In theory, Hiroki Ito is another option. The Japanese player, injury-free for the first time in a long while, has played just 115 minutes this season. He did complete 90 minutes against second-division side 1. FC Magdeburg in the DFB Cup at the end of October, but at centre-back. Coach Vincent Kompany evidently no longer considers him a serious option.
Davies was deeply frustrated after going off at the weekend. Following a torn muscle bundle in the closing stages of last season, he had even held back at the World Cup in his home country, playing just 16 minutes and drawing plenty of criticism from Canadian fans. He was "a little frustrated and angry", Davies told Canadian sports broadcaster OneSoccer. Repeated thigh injuries were "no fun", he said. "I lost it in the dressing room. I didn’t know what was going on," Davies explained, admitting that he had also broken a few bins.
Alphonso Davies' lengthy injury record: his muscle injuries are no coincidence
Davies' injury record explains his reaction. This is his fourth muscle tear since December 2024. Since arriving in Munich in January 2019, he has missed 129 matches. Since his lucrative contract extension in early 2025 alone, he has spent more days out than some footballers do over an entire professional career. His longest absence began with the most serious injury of his career to date:
| 24 March to 8 December 2025: torn cruciate ligament (including time spent regaining training fitness) | 4 January to 15 January 2026: illness | 22 February to 9 March 2026: muscle tear |
| 11 March to 2 April 2026: thigh injury | 7 May to 11 June 2026: muscle injury | since 15 November 2026: muscle tear |
Davies has repeatedly struggled with muscle problems since his cruciate ligament injury, which he also sustained on international duty. The association initially failed to diagnose it, leading to a bitter dispute with Bayern. Such problems are not uncommon in professional football. A study published in the American Journal of Sports Medicine shows that almost one in three professionals experience this "phenomenon" within the first year after returning. According to the study, players who have needed cruciate ligament reconstruction surgery face more than two and a half times the risk of uninjured players.
In figures, around 32.5 per cent sustain at least one muscle injury within the first twelve months of their return, compared with about 12.5 per cent in the healthy comparison group. Davies' first two muscle tears, however, occurred a few months before his cruciate ligament tear.
The repeated problems in the same area also worry Davies. Having four injuries to the back of the thigh "is something you have to be very careful with. If you keep suffering the same injury, something could eventually give way, and then we’re talking about surgery. That’s something I’m afraid of. It’s just really hard," he said.
Davies and coach Jesse Marsch also revealed to OneSoccer that he had felt "a little pain towards my knee, at the lower end of my hamstring" before the match. The medical department took it seriously and arranged an MRI scan, but it showed nothing abnormal. "It showed there was no problem. So I said: OK."
Davies now wants to do everything he can to "stay positive", "focus on my recovery and try to come back as quickly and safely as possible".
Alphonso Davies no longer untouchable? Bayern Munich face a dilemma
That raises the question again of whether Bayern did themselves any favours by extending his contract until 2030. After lengthy negotiations, the club's leadership, headed by sporting director Max Eberl, eventually gave him a reported base salary of €15 million. Bonuses could allegedly increase it considerably, while he also received a signing-on fee of around €20 million.
Bayern did, however, take precautions. According to Sport Bild, the Bundesliga leaders continue to pay Davies' full salary for three to four months if he is out through injury, whereas the period for Jamal Musiala, for example, is six months. Like any other employer, Bayern are only obliged to guarantee continued pay for six weeks in the event of illness. From the seventh week, Germany's statutory health insurer takes over, with payments capped at €5,812.50 gross per month.
Given his hefty salary, rumours were already circulating in the spring, with kicker among those reporting that Davies was no longer untouchable. The latest setback raises fresh doubts about whether he can shake off his reputation for frequent injuries, and whether Bayern would be better off parting ways with him. Brown gives them a top alternative who is also a Germany international. On the other hand, few clubs would be willing to offer such a generous salary to a left-back with Davies' injury history.
That leaves Bayern with a dilemma. Davies could yet return quickly to his previous level and make the question of a sale irrelevant. By then, he will at least have put the difficult year after his cruciate ligament injury behind him.
Alphonso Davies: statistics and performances for Bayern Munich
| Statistic | 2026/27 season | Total |
| Appearances | 15 | 264 |
| Goals | 3 | 18 |
| Assists | 5 | 45 |
| Matches missed | 0 (so far) | 129 |